| Patrick Hoban Centre-Forward | 10/11 | Mervue United A.F.C. Bristol City | 44 | 11/12 | | 27 | 365 |
| Dennis Behan Centre-Forward | 09/10 | Cork City FC Hartlepool United | 0 | 11/12 | | 28 | 708 |
| Joe Gamble Central Midfield | 09/10 | Cork City FC Hartlepool United | 0 | 11/12 | | 22 | 546 |
| Peter Hutton Centre-Back | 09/10 | Derry City Cliftonville FC | 0 | 10/11 | | 8 | 455 |
| Christy Connaghan Right Midfield | 09/10 | Finn Harps Fanad United | 28 | 10/11 | | 8 | 365 |
| Stephen O'Flynn Centre-Forward | 09/10 | Limerick FC (- 2019) Northampton Town | 48 | 10/11 | | 10 | 181 |
| Tony Shields Central Midfield | 08/09 | Finn Harps Coleraine FC | 32 | 10/11 | | 0 | 730 |
| Kevin McHugh Centre-Forward | 06/07 | Finn Harps Derry City | 44 | 09/10 | | 146 | 1.280 |
| Thomas Bonnar Central Midfield | 08/09 | Finn Harps Institute FC | 5 | 09/10 | | 97 | 365 |
| Matthew Crossan Left-Back | 08/09 | Finn Harps Coleraine FC | 18 | 09/10 | | 57 | 365 |
| Sean Roddy Central Midfield | 08/09 | Finn Harps Institute FC | 23 | 09/10 | | 0 | 396 |
| Brian Kelly
| 06/07 | Dundalk FC Newry City AFC | 9 | 07/08 | | 17 | 365 |
| David Bracken Centre-Forward | 06/07 | Shelbourne FC Glenavon FC | 0 | 07/08 | | 4 | 365 |
| Pat Jennings Goalkeeper | 03/04 | University College Dublin Derry City | 0 | 07/08 | | 0 | 1.645 |
| David Rogers Left-Back | 06/07 | Shelbourne FC Derry City | 0 | 07/08 | | 0 | 181 |
| Alvin Rouse Goalkeeper | 04/05 | Sligo Rovers Barbados Defence Force SC | 19 | 06/07 | | 24 | 789 |
| Robbie Farrell Centre-Forward | 04/05 | Dublin City FC (- 2006) Newry City AFC | 23 | 06/07 | | 33 | 914 |
| Ryan Casey Left-Back | 05/06 | Galway United FC Melbourne Knights | 27 | 06/07 | | 20 | 365 |
| Seamus Brown
| 05/06 | Finn Harps Derry City | 0 | 06/07 | | 22 | 549 |
| Thomas McGauley
| 05/06 | Limerick FC (- 2019) Armagh City FC | 1 | 06/07 | | 0 | 181 |
| Alan Murphy Central Midfield | 04/05 | Galway United FC Derry City | 20 | 05/06 | | 38 | 549 |
| Ciarán Kelly Goalkeeper | 03/04 | Sligo Rovers Derry City | 24 | 04/05 | | 0 | 366 |
| John Connolly Goalkeeper | 02/03 | Dundalk FC Crusaders FC | 0 | 04/05 | | 4 | 700 |
| David Hoey
| 02/03 | Dundalk FC Newry City AFC | 0 | 04/05 | | 40 | 550 |
| Andrew Duffy
| 03/04 | Dundalk FC Newry City AFC | 9 | 04/05 | | 9 | 335 |