| Jack Larkin Centre-Forward | 21/22 | Cobh Ramblers FC MSU Mustangs (Midwestern State University) | 18 | 23/24 | | 5 | 552 |
| Jaze Kabia Right Winger | 20/21 | Shelbourne FC Livingston FC | 5 | 23/24 | | 0 | 928 |
| Yousef Mahdy Centre-Forward | 22/23 | Finn Harps Olympic Alexandria | 0 | 23/24 | | 0 | 344 |
| Adam Wixted Right Winger | 21/22 | Athlone Town AFC Warrenpoint Town FC | 21 | 23/24 | | 4 | 549 |
| Daniel McKenna Defensive Midfield | 21/22 | Athlone Town AFC Warrenpoint Town FC | 22 | 23/24 | | 6 | 551 |
| Dylan Hand Left-Back | 21/22 | Athlone Town AFC Warrenpoint Town FC | 25 | 23/24 | | 0 | 551 |
| Cian Lynch Centre-Forward | 17/18 | Cabinteely FC (- 2021) Savannah College of Art and Design | 3 | 22/23 | | 5 | 1.994 |
| Ibrahim Keita Centre-Forward | 17/18 | Finn Harps FK Olympia Radotin | 0 | 22/23 | | 9 | 1.819 |
| Kevin Williams Right-Back | 21/22 | Cobh Ramblers FC FC International Leipzig | 4 | 22/23 | | 40 | 584 |
| Katlego Mashigo Central Midfield | 21/22 | Waterford FC Portadown FC | 0 | 22/23 | | 17 | 368 |
| Maurice Nugent Centre-Back | 21/22 | Galway United FC Hendon FC | 74 | 22/23 | | 30 | 365 |
| Mikie Rowe Centre-Forward | 15/16 | Waterford FC YHC Athletics (Young Harris College) | 18 | 20/21 | | 55 | 1.980 |
| Conor O'Keeffe Right-Back | 16/17 | Wexford FC Southern United (2004 - 2020) | 0 | 20/21 | | 64 | 1.547 |
| Lee Duffy Centre-Forward | 18/19 | Drogheda United FC Warrenpoint Town FC | 17 | 20/21 | | 5 | 570 |
| Joe Gorman Centre-Back | 15/16 | Drogheda United FC Maidenhead United | 0 | 19/20 | | 10 | 1.472 |
| Seán Russell Left Midfield | 17/18 | Drogheda United FC Atlantic City FC | 0 | 18/19 | | 0 | 205 |
| Danny Furlong Centre-Forward | 16/17 | Wexford FC Southern United (2004 - 2020) | 169 | 17/18 | | 15 | 439 |
| Ryan Swan Centre-Forward | 16/17 | University College Dublin Exeter City | 54 | 17/18 | | 0 | 150 |
| Raymond Foy Central Midfield | 11/12 | Finn Harps Derry City | 5 | 14/15 | | 24 | 1.308 |
| Ciaran Gallagher Goalkeeper | 13/14 | Finn Harps Derry City | 113 | 14/15 | | 54 | 365 |
| Jack Doherty Attacking Midfield | 13/14 | Waterford FC Ipswich Town | 36 | 13/14 | | 27 | 213 |
| Don Cowan Right Winger | 11/12 | Longford Town FC Stevenage FC | 32 | 13/14 | | 42 | 850 |
| Marc Brolly Left Midfield | 11/12 | Finn Harps Dungannon Swifts FC | 92 | 12/13 | | 10 | 366 |
| Gary Curran Central Midfield | 11/12 | Finn Harps Ballinamallard United FC | 9 | 12/13 | | 23 | 366 |
| Michael Funston Right Midfield | 10/11 | Finn Harps Dungannon Swifts FC | 98 | 12/13 | | 73 | 547 |